Demographics Study: In 15 years Columbia MO joins non-white cities

Demographic Study: In 20 Years, Will Columbia, Missouri Join with all the rest of the non-white cities?

A comparison of Columbia’s present demographic position with American cities that passed through a similar stage of demographic change.

Columbia, Missouri is growing. Development, employment, education and new housing continue to attract residents from outside the region, while the city’s racial and ethnic composition is changing along with its population.

According to current U.S. Census data, approximately 71.7% of Columbia’s population is non-Hispanic White. In other words, approximately 28.3% of the city falls outside that category.

That number is worth studying because several growing American cities reached a similar demographic position in previous decades. What happened during the following ten or twenty years provides useful comparisons — although not a guaranteed forecast of Columbia’s future.

1. Columbia, Missouri: Where We Are Now

Columbia Missouri White versus other population demographic trend

Columbia: approximately 71.7% non-Hispanic White / 28.3% other

Columbia’s change has been gradual compared with many larger metropolitan areas. Nevertheless, the long-term direction has been toward a more racially and ethnically diverse population.

The question is not whether Columbia has changed — it clearly has. The more interesting question is what cities at roughly this stage of demographic transition looked like ten and twenty years later.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Columbia city, Missouri QuickFacts, 2020–2024.

 

2. Detroit: The Large-City Historical Example

Detroit Michigan White versus other population demographic trend 1940 to present

Detroit demonstrates just how dramatically a city’s demographic composition can change over several generations.

Detroit is not a direct comparison with Columbia because of its much greater historical population and its extraordinary postwar population loss.

It is useful, however, as the familiar long-term example. Detroit moved from an overwhelmingly White city in 1940 to a city in which non-Hispanic Whites represent only a small minority today.

The lesson from Detroit is therefore historical rather than predictive: urban demographic composition can change far more substantially within a lifetime than many residents assume.

The More Relevant Comparison: Cities Around Columbia’s Size

Detroit is dramatic, but Richardson, Texas and Kent, Washington provide more useful comparisons for Columbia.

Around the year 2000, both had reached roughly the demographic range Columbia occupies today.

What happened next is particularly noteworthy.

3. Richardson, Texas: The Closest Comparison

Richardson Texas demographic transition White versus other population

2000: 69.6% non-Hispanic White
2010: 58.1%
2020: 50.5%

Richardson is particularly interesting because its position in 2000 looked remarkably similar to Columbia’s position today.

Richardson had approximately 91,800 residents in 2000 and was 69.6% non-Hispanic White. Twenty years later, the population had increased to approximately 119,500 while the non-Hispanic White share had fallen to approximately 50.5%.

Current Census estimates place Richardson below the 50% mark.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau. Richardson population: 91,802 in 2000; 99,223 in 2010; 119,469 in 2020.


4. Kent, Washington: The Faster Transition

Kent Washington demographic transition White versus other population

2000: 67.9% non-Hispanic White
2010: 49.7%
2020: 37.4%

Kent represents a considerably faster version of the same demographic trajectory.

In 2000, Kent was approximately 67.9% non-Hispanic White — only a few percentage points below Columbia today.

Only ten years later, that figure had fallen below 50%. By 2020 it was approximately 37.4%.

Kent’s population was also growing rather than collapsing: from approximately 79,500 in 2000 to more than 136,000 in 2020.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau decennial Census data.

5. Aurora, Illinois: A Mature Example

Aurora Illinois demographic transition White versus other population

2000: 52.1% non-Hispanic White
2010: 39.9%
2020: 33.8%

Aurora had already progressed considerably farther along this demographic transition by 2000.

Its non-Hispanic White population declined from approximately 52.1% in 2000 to approximately 39.9% in 2010 and 33.8% by 2020.

Aurora therefore shows what a city can look like after the demographic crossover has already occurred.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau and Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning.

Columbia Today Compared With Other Cities

City / Period Non-Hispanic White All Others
Columbia today 71.7% 28.3%
Richardson, 2000 69.6% 30.4%
Richardson, 2020 50.5% 49.5%
Kent, 2000 67.9% 32.1%
Kent, 2010 49.7% 50.3%
Kent, 2020 37.4% 62.6%
Aurora, 2000 52.1% 47.9%
Aurora, 2020 33.8% 66.2%

What Does This Suggest for Columbia?

Columbia is presently in a demographic range that several other growing American cities occupied roughly one or two decades before reaching a point at which non-Hispanic Whites represented approximately half — or less than half — of their populations.

Richardson went from approximately 70% to 50% in twenty years.

Kent went from approximately 68% to below 50% in only ten years.

Those histories make a substantial demographic change in Columbia over the next twenty years a plausible scenario.

They do not, however, establish an automatic demographic threshold. Columbia’s future composition will depend upon migration, births, deaths, employment, university enrollment, housing construction, economic development and other local conditions.

The significant point is simpler: Columbia is no longer at the beginning of demographic diversification. It is already approximately 28% outside the non-Hispanic White category, placing it near demographic positions previously occupied by several cities that changed substantially over the following decade or two.

Methodology Note

For modern comparisons, “White” refers to the U.S. Census category “White alone, not Hispanic or Latino.” “All others” represents the remainder of the population so that the two categories are mutually exclusive. Historical Census racial classifications have changed over time, particularly in older Detroit data, and should therefore be interpreted with appropriate caution. Comparisons between cities illustrate possible trajectories rather than deterministic forecasts.

Prepared as a demographic study for the Salem Institute of Peace Studies.


Additional Context: Refugee Resettlement in Columbia and Mid-Missouri

Recent public discussion surrounding comments by Heather Overstreet
has raised questions about the number of refugees and Muslims living in Columbia,
Missouri. Rather than either exaggerating or dismissing the numbers, we examined
several publicly available sources to determine what can actually be documented.

More Than 4,000 Refugees Resettled Through the Mid-Missouri Program

There is also a much broader documented historical number.
Catholic Charities of Central and Northern Missouri reported
in 2021 that its refugee program had resettled more than 4,000
refugees from around the world over approximately four decades.

This is significant evidence of longstanding organized refugee resettlement
in the region. The geographic distinction is important, however:
the 4,000+ figure refers to the Mid-Missouri program and should not
be represented as 4,000 people necessarily resettled within Columbia city
limits.
Read the 2021 Catholic Missourian report

Columbia’s Islamic Center: Up to 1,500 at Eid in 2017

A separate published figure provides context for the size of Columbia’s
Muslim community.

In January 2017 — nearly a decade ago — KBIA reported that
the Islamic Center of Central Missouri estimated approximately
600–700 people attended Friday prayers, while attendance
during the two major Eid observances would reach approximately
1,500 people.

That number is particularly useful because it predates the recent controversy
by many years. At the same time, an Eid attendance estimate is
not the same thing as a Census population count, nor does it
establish that those 1,500 people were refugees. It is evidence specifically
of participation in major Islamic religious observances in Columbia at that
time. Read the January 31, 2017 KBIA report

Afghan Refugee Resettlement After 2021

The resettlement infrastructure became particularly visible following the
2021 evacuation from Afghanistan. By late 2022, Catholic Charities reported
that it had assisted nearly 300 Afghan allies in the Columbia, Fulton and Jefferson City area. The scope of infrastructure typically ranges in around a dozen supporters for every 1 Afghan refugee.

This represents a documented recent example of refugees being received and
assisted through an organized resettlement network in Mid-Missouri. Read the December 2022 Catholic Missourian report

City of Refuge: A 1,500+ Figure and a Three-Month Window

One publicly available LinkedIn employment record documents a
three-month internship with City of Refuge in Columbia,
running from June 2023 through August 2023.

The description identifies the position as a
Nonprofit Operations and Management Intern and describes
activities including distributing clothing, food and school supplies to
refugees in the community, obtaining donations from local businesses and
assisting the organization’s executive directors with fundraising activities.

The same publicly available résumé/profile has also been associated with the
figure of “1,500+ refugees in Columbia, MO.” The short
three-month employment period makes the context of that figure particularly
noteworthy.

There is, however, an important distinction: a figure describing refugees
assisted or served by City of Refuge should not automatically
be interpreted as meaning that 1,500 refugees were newly resettled
during those three months. The LinkedIn material establishes the internship
period and describes direct refugee-assistance work, but the precise meaning
and time span represented by the 1,500+ figure should be stated only as broadly
as the original source supports. View City of Refuge on LinkedIn

Over 300 Afghans (sometimes the bad ones) were imported directly into the area of Columbia Missouri during the height of war there. Normally for every 1 refugee there are dozens of supporters.

Setting the Record Straight

The controversy surrounding Heather Overstreet’s comments should therefore
be considered alongside the documented record rather than reduced to a single
number.

The available sources establish several separate facts:

  • A publicly available LinkedIn employment record documents refugee-assistance
    work with City of Refuge in Columbia during a three-month internship
    from June through August 2023
    , while the associated profile material
    references 1,500+ refugees in Columbia, Missouri.
  • Catholic Charities reported that its longstanding
    Mid-Missouri refugee program had resettled more than 4,000 refugees
    from around the world over approximately four decades.
  • Following the Afghanistan evacuation, Catholic Charities reported assisting
    nearly 300 Afghan allies in Columbia, Fulton and Jefferson City. (typically these aren’t just left on their own)
  • As far back as 2017, Columbia’s Islamic Center reported
    600–700 Friday-prayer attendees and attendance reaching
    approximately 1,500 at major Eid observances.

What these sources do not establish is that exactly
1,500 Muslim refugees were brought into Columbia in a single
resettlement operation.
Refugee status, religious affiliation,
people served by a nonprofit and people formally resettled are different
measurements and should not be conflated.

What is documented is that Columbia and Mid-Missouri have
participated in organized refugee resettlement for decades, that the number
resettled through the regional program reaches into the thousands, and that
Columbia already had a substantial Muslim religious community documented
nearly a decade ago.

References

City of Refuge / LinkedIn: City of Refuge — LinkedIn

Catholic Charities — 4,000+ refugees: The Catholic Missourian — September 2021

Islamic Center — 1,500 Eid attendance: KBIA — January 31, 2017